933
The Newman Letters: A Catholic College at Oxford? Newman (Rev. Fr. John Henry, later Cardinal, now
1/3
Description
The Newman Letters: A Catholic College at Oxford? Newman (Rev. Fr. John Henry, later Cardinal, now Saint) A very good collection of 24 A.L.S. to [Thomas] Gaisford of the Gaisford St. Lawrence family of Howth Castle, with other related letters, drafts and documents, mostly 1863-67 with a few later, the collection outlining in detail how Newman?s visionary plan to establish a Catholic College at Oxford was frustrated and eventually prevented by the Catholic hierarchy of the time. Thomas Gaisford came of a prosperous Wiltshire family who made money from water-mills in the 18th-century (see catalogue introduction).ÿ His father (also Thomas, d. 1855) was a scholar, and became Regius Professor of Greek at Oxford University and Dean of Christ Church in Oxford.ÿ He married as his second wife Lady Emily St. Lawrence, eldest daughter of the fourth Earl of Howth in Ireland.ÿ The Earl had no male issue, and on his death in 1909 his will left the Howth estate to his son-in-law and family, who moved to Ireland and adopted the name Gaisford St. Lawrence. Thomas Gaisford (junior) was influenced by the Oxford Movement as a young man, and evidently became a friend of John Henry Newman.ÿ After the death of his father, Thomas became a Catholic. John Henry Newman (1801-1890) was ordained a priest in the Church of England in 1825.ÿ He became a Fellow of Oriel College, and in 1828 he became Vicar of St. Mary?s, the Oxford university church, and built a reputation as a preacher, but he had difficulties with church teaching, and in 1845 he was received into the Catholic Churchÿ -ÿ a significant and high-profile conversion.ÿ He became a Catholic priest in 1847, and was appointed the founding superior in England of the Congregation of the Oratory, based in Birmingham where he met many Irish people. In 1851 he was contacted by Archbishop Paul Cullen of Armagh, who wanted to found a Catholic university in Dublin.ÿ Newman agreed to become its first Rector, and developed his plans in a series of lectures which later became The Idea of a University, his most celebrated work.ÿ However, the Catholic University was not a success.ÿ His appointment of English friends as lecturers led to opposition, and he finally resigned in 1858 and returned to England, where he soon turned to a new project. The correspondence here is mainly about Newman?s plans to found a Catholic college (including a branch of the Oratory) in Oxford, on a 5-acre plot of land purchased from one Ambrose Smith (see undated letter), with sponsorship from Gaisford and others.ÿ On 16 August 1864 he asks Gaisfordÿ ?if you think it worth while to co-operate with other gentlemen in purchasing the ground?.ÿ Gaisford?s draft reply says, ?I am ready to join in any scheme for establishing a Catholic college or Hub at Oxford, if I can see a fair chance of success .. the site seems to be eligible & not very dear, if other Cath. gentlemen would unite to purchase it?, and offers to subscribe œ500 or even more.ÿ Newman replies on 20 August that ?there are many persons of influence opposed to the idea of a [Catholic] College at Oxford?, and says his idea for the moment is simply to acquire the site.ÿ On 1 September, and again on 4 September, ÿhe outlines detailed plans for a College, an Oratory, a church, a priest?s house etc., all costed in detail, buying land with frontage on the street at 10/- the square yard.ÿ ?Of course if we could get another œ1000, we could go nearly 50 ft. deeper into the land .. which would be a great advantage.?ÿ On 20 September, ?We have this morning settled to buy 2 « acres of Mr. Smith?s ground .. How we are to raise the money, œ4630, I do not know.ÿ It will be more, for we shall have to build a long wall to cut the ground off from the restÿ -ÿ and we shall be tempted to buy, if we can, the whole or part of the existing buildings upon it.? On 28 September he reports that ?the [Catholic] Bishop has told me, what in substance I knew before, till Propaganda [Fidei, a Church department] decides the matter, no ecclesiastical can take any step which is of the nature of a co-operation with the University and College of Oxford.ÿ This, however, does not of course apply to the provisional purchase of ground, or to any act on the part of laymen.?ÿ Then on 25 October, ?The owner, Mr. Smith, suddenly broke a blood vessel and died.ÿ That led to his family wishing to get rid of the ground at once and altogether, and St. John?s College offered to take the wholeÿ .. We have been forced, yesterday, to buy the whole for œ8,400, as the alternative of losing every part of it.? A long and interesting letter on 30 October 1864 sums up his position.ÿ ?In nothing can one have one?s own will, pure and simpleÿ -ÿ and the difficulty is increased, when one is not sure what one?s will is.ÿ The College or Hall scheme is enveloped in difficulty.ÿ I am inclined to think that it is the best plan for Catholics under their circumstances, in a religious point of view, a university of their own neither answering the purpose they have before them, nor possibleÿ ..ÿÿ Now here I find a strong,ÿ I may say, a growing feeling on the part of the Bishops against itÿ .. Catholic gentlemen are beginning to prefer sending their boys to the existing Colleges, some have been doing so from the firstÿ ..? Nevertheless, he pressed ahead, writing on 29 December a circular letter to Gaisford and others, seeking subscriptions; a receipt in January acknowledges œ200 fromÿ Gaisford, and his contribution appears in a printed circular dated July 1866, headed ?The Oratory, Oxford?, listing over 60 contributions totalling several thousand pounds. Then, in March 1867, a bombshell.ÿ ?You may recollect that in the Autumn of 1864, I sent you the draft or proof sheet of a circular I intended to issue .. the Cardinal heard of it, was very angry because there was mention in it, not of the Oratory?s taking part in education at Oxford, but merely ?taking the religious charge? of the young Catholics there.ÿ He sent a copy of it (which he got without my leave) to Romeÿ -ÿ and a prejudice has been created against me there ever since. ?Accordingly, in the new Circular which you have, there is not a word in recognition of the fact of Catholic youths being at Oxford at all.ÿ I was forbidden to allude to them. ?But this is not all.ÿ Last Monday (I say it in confidence) comes a Letter to me from Propaganda [Fidei] to the effect that they hear I have in my school some boys preparing for Oxford, and solemnly ordering me neither directly nor indirectly by any act to favour youths going there.? Eventually, in July 1872, Newman writes that ?As there is now at length no chance at all of the Oratory going to Oxford, the questionÿ arises how you would wish me to dispose of the œ200 which you so generously contributed to it.? Gaisford?s response is not recorded here.ÿ The collection also includes several draft letters from Gaisford (much amended) outlining his views on the Oxford project, mainly on financial aspects; also some later letters from Newman, who clearly remained a family friend. An interesting and significant correspondence.ÿ Clearly Newman was capable of adopting what some would consider devious means towards an end, but if so he met his match in Rome. Fr. Newman was canonised as Saint John Henry Newman in 2019. As a collection.ÿ The letters are generally in excellent condition. (As a lot)
Auction Details
Shipping
T&Cs & Important Info
Ask seller a question
The Newman Letters: A Catholic College at Oxford? Newman (Rev. Fr. John Henry, later Cardinal, now Saint) A very good collection of 24 A.L.S. to [Thomas] Gaisford of the Gaisford St. Lawrence family of Howth Castle, with other related letters, drafts and documents, mostly 1863-67 with a few later, the collection outlining in detail how Newman?s visionary plan to establish a Catholic College at Oxford was frustrated and eventually prevented by the Catholic hierarchy of the time. Thomas Gaisford came of a prosperous Wiltshire family who made money from water-mills in the 18th-century (see catalogue introduction).ÿ His father (also Thomas, d. 1855) was a scholar, and became Regius Professor of Greek at Oxford University and Dean of Christ Church in Oxford.ÿ He married as his second wife Lady Emily St. Lawrence, eldest daughter of the fourth Earl of Howth in Ireland.ÿ The Earl had no male issue, and on his death in 1909 his will left the Howth estate to his son-in-law and family, who moved to Ireland and adopted the name Gaisford St. Lawrence. Thomas Gaisford (junior) was influenced by the Oxford Movement as a young man, and evidently became a friend of John Henry Newman.ÿ After the death of his father, Thomas became a Catholic. John Henry Newman (1801-1890) was ordained a priest in the Church of England in 1825.ÿ He became a Fellow of Oriel College, and in 1828 he became Vicar of St. Mary?s, the Oxford university church, and built a reputation as a preacher, but he had difficulties with church teaching, and in 1845 he was received into the Catholic Churchÿ -ÿ a significant and high-profile conversion.ÿ He became a Catholic priest in 1847, and was appointed the founding superior in England of the Congregation of the Oratory, based in Birmingham where he met many Irish people. In 1851 he was contacted by Archbishop Paul Cullen of Armagh, who wanted to found a Catholic university in Dublin.ÿ Newman agreed to become its first Rector, and developed his plans in a series of lectures which later became The Idea of a University, his most celebrated work.ÿ However, the Catholic University was not a success.ÿ His appointment of English friends as lecturers led to opposition, and he finally resigned in 1858 and returned to England, where he soon turned to a new project. The correspondence here is mainly about Newman?s plans to found a Catholic college (including a branch of the Oratory) in Oxford, on a 5-acre plot of land purchased from one Ambrose Smith (see undated letter), with sponsorship from Gaisford and others.ÿ On 16 August 1864 he asks Gaisfordÿ ?if you think it worth while to co-operate with other gentlemen in purchasing the ground?.ÿ Gaisford?s draft reply says, ?I am ready to join in any scheme for establishing a Catholic college or Hub at Oxford, if I can see a fair chance of success .. the site seems to be eligible & not very dear, if other Cath. gentlemen would unite to purchase it?, and offers to subscribe œ500 or even more.ÿ Newman replies on 20 August that ?there are many persons of influence opposed to the idea of a [Catholic] College at Oxford?, and says his idea for the moment is simply to acquire the site.ÿ On 1 September, and again on 4 September, ÿhe outlines detailed plans for a College, an Oratory, a church, a priest?s house etc., all costed in detail, buying land with frontage on the street at 10/- the square yard.ÿ ?Of course if we could get another œ1000, we could go nearly 50 ft. deeper into the land .. which would be a great advantage.?ÿ On 20 September, ?We have this morning settled to buy 2 « acres of Mr. Smith?s ground .. How we are to raise the money, œ4630, I do not know.ÿ It will be more, for we shall have to build a long wall to cut the ground off from the restÿ -ÿ and we shall be tempted to buy, if we can, the whole or part of the existing buildings upon it.? On 28 September he reports that ?the [Catholic] Bishop has told me, what in substance I knew before, till Propaganda [Fidei, a Church department] decides the matter, no ecclesiastical can take any step which is of the nature of a co-operation with the University and College of Oxford.ÿ This, however, does not of course apply to the provisional purchase of ground, or to any act on the part of laymen.?ÿ Then on 25 October, ?The owner, Mr. Smith, suddenly broke a blood vessel and died.ÿ That led to his family wishing to get rid of the ground at once and altogether, and St. John?s College offered to take the wholeÿ .. We have been forced, yesterday, to buy the whole for œ8,400, as the alternative of losing every part of it.? A long and interesting letter on 30 October 1864 sums up his position.ÿ ?In nothing can one have one?s own will, pure and simpleÿ -ÿ and the difficulty is increased, when one is not sure what one?s will is.ÿ The College or Hall scheme is enveloped in difficulty.ÿ I am inclined to think that it is the best plan for Catholics under their circumstances, in a religious point of view, a university of their own neither answering the purpose they have before them, nor possibleÿ ..ÿÿ Now here I find a strong,ÿ I may say, a growing feeling on the part of the Bishops against itÿ .. Catholic gentlemen are beginning to prefer sending their boys to the existing Colleges, some have been doing so from the firstÿ ..? Nevertheless, he pressed ahead, writing on 29 December a circular letter to Gaisford and others, seeking subscriptions; a receipt in January acknowledges œ200 fromÿ Gaisford, and his contribution appears in a printed circular dated July 1866, headed ?The Oratory, Oxford?, listing over 60 contributions totalling several thousand pounds. Then, in March 1867, a bombshell.ÿ ?You may recollect that in the Autumn of 1864, I sent you the draft or proof sheet of a circular I intended to issue .. the Cardinal heard of it, was very angry because there was mention in it, not of the Oratory?s taking part in education at Oxford, but merely ?taking the religious charge? of the young Catholics there.ÿ He sent a copy of it (which he got without my leave) to Romeÿ -ÿ and a prejudice has been created against me there ever since. ?Accordingly, in the new Circular which you have, there is not a word in recognition of the fact of Catholic youths being at Oxford at all.ÿ I was forbidden to allude to them. ?But this is not all.ÿ Last Monday (I say it in confidence) comes a Letter to me from Propaganda [Fidei] to the effect that they hear I have in my school some boys preparing for Oxford, and solemnly ordering me neither directly nor indirectly by any act to favour youths going there.? Eventually, in July 1872, Newman writes that ?As there is now at length no chance at all of the Oratory going to Oxford, the questionÿ arises how you would wish me to dispose of the œ200 which you so generously contributed to it.? Gaisford?s response is not recorded here.ÿ The collection also includes several draft letters from Gaisford (much amended) outlining his views on the Oxford project, mainly on financial aspects; also some later letters from Newman, who clearly remained a family friend. An interesting and significant correspondence.ÿ Clearly Newman was capable of adopting what some would consider devious means towards an end, but if so he met his match in Rome. Fr. Newman was canonised as Saint John Henry Newman in 2019. As a collection.ÿ The letters are generally in excellent condition. (As a lot)
Howth Castle Library Sale - 800 Years of History
Sale Date(s)
Lots: 1 - 552
Lots: 600- 1083
Venue Address
The Marine Hotel
Sutton Cross
Sutton
Co Dublin
.D13 PEY8
Ireland
Collection from Howth Castle - No Collections on sale days.
Collections - From 12 Noon - 4.00 pm Friday 24th September and resuming on Monday 27th Septmber at 12 Noon until 4 pm -and subsequent weekdays. No collections available at weekends.
We request that all items purchased must be collected from the sale vanue ( Howth Castle ) by 15.00 on Friday. 24th September.
Overseas purchasers are requested to arrange collection and shipment as soon as possible, and by no later than Friday, 1st October.
We recommend the following Shipping Companies to assist you with collection and shipment.
Please contact them directly to obtain shipping cost quote, delivery schedule, etc.
For; Books & Manuscripts :
Mail Boxes Etc ,Dublin. Tel. 01.6710400 Email info@mbedublin2.com
Pack and Send Belfast . Tel ; +44 (0) 2890 219003 Email belfasteast@packsend.co.uk
For Larger Items.
Gibbons Removals Kilkenny 056.7760444 Email info@gibbonsremovals.com
Tel: +353 (0)57 87 36596
Web: www.MovingHome.ie E-mail: info@movinghome.ie
Carlyle Fine Art Services ; Dublin. Tel; 087.2890898 Email david@davidcarlyle.ie
Oman Removals and Storage ,Kill Co. Kildare. Tel 045.886300 Email info@oman.ie
Important Information
Viewing on the Premises at Howth Castle, Howth, Co. Dublin. Ireland. D13 EH73.
Auction to be conducted at The Marine Hotel, Sutton Cross, Sutton, Co. Dublin. D13 PEY8.
Attendance at the auction on sale days subject to prevailing Covi-19 restrictions.
The auctioneers reserve the right to refuse admission to viewing and sale.
- Fine Greek, Latin, Italian, French, German & English Volumes from 1515-1920.
- Together with other Important books on Travel, Botany, History, etc.
- Important Original Manuscript Work and Correspondence (include 24 A.L.s. from Saint John Henry Newman) Signed, Presentation and annotated Copies etc., together with important Periodicals in large runs.
- To also include a rare collection of early Books by George Berkeley, fine coloured Plate Books of Botanical and Travel interest, good collection of 19th Century English Poetry etc., Photographs and a good collection of Material, Atlases, Addresses, and Manuscripts, Scrap Albums of Watercolours & Prints, Photograph Albums, etc., relating to the Gaisford-St. Lawrence Family and the local area of Howth Castle Estate. Approx. 1,000 lots
- The Entire Contents of the Howth Castle Library is generally in fine original condition
- and in fine bindings.
Terms & Conditions
Buyer's Premium 25 % (VAT inclusive) applicable to all lots purchased. Online bidding surcharge of 5 % applicable..
We accept payment by Debit / Credit Cards (credit card payments from outside the E.U. will incur 3% surcharge).
Payment by direct bank transfer , guaranteed cheque.
Catalogue Abbreviations : Paintings, Prints, Works of Art, Furniture, etc.
The first name or names and surname of the Artist or Craftsman: In our opinion a work by the Artist of Craftsman. Attributed to: In our opinion probably a work by the Artist or Craftsman but less certainty as to authorship is expressed than in the preceding category.
Studio of: In our opinion a work that may have been executed in whole or in part by the artist's hand. Circle of: In our opinion a work of the period of the Artist or Craftsman that is in a similar style to the work of that Artist or Craftsman.
The surname of the Artist or Craftsman, preceded by “After”: In our opinion, a copy of the work of the artist or craftsman.
Signed – Stamped: Has a signature or stamp, which in our opinion is the signature or stamp of the artist or craftsman.
Bears Signature or Stamp: Has a signature or stamp, which in our opinion might be the signature or stamp of the artist or craftsman.
Dated: Is so dated and in our opinion was executed at about that date.
Bears Date: Is so dated and in our opinion may have been executed at about that date.
Abbreviations
O.O.C. Oils on Canvas O .O.P. Oils on Panel
O.O.B. Oils on Board W/C Watercolour
GOU Gouache MAH. Mahogany
VICT. Victorian ED W. Edwardian
W.A.F. With all faults As Is With all damages, faults, restorations, etc.
S.N.S.R. Sold not subject to return..
Catalogue Abbreviations ; Books and Manuscripts
mls Manuscript Letters signed
als Autographed Letters signed
acs Autographed Cards signed
pb Paperback
a.e.g. All edges gilt
t.e.g Top edge gilt
w.a.f. With all faults
As is With all damages , faults, restorations.
As a lot With all faults , As is
L.S.s Library stamps
S.N.S.R. Sold not subject to return
Publ. Published
f.e.p. Front end paper
mor Morocco
n.d. No date
n.p. No place
d.j. Dust jacket
L.P. Large paper
h.m.p. Hand made paper
vell. Vellum
hf. Half
d.w.s. Dust wrappers
I.M.C. Irish M/ss Commission
A.M.S Armorial motif on spine
cont. Contemporary
n.a.t. Not affecting text
frontis Frontispiece
engd. Engraved
cold. Coloured
hd. Hand
port. Portrait
N.B.: Please note the auctioneers offer no After Sale Guarantee
whatsoever, with regard to mechanical and electrical items, or
firearms. We accept no subsequent liability for any damage, loss or
injury arising from the use of the foregoing.
IMPORTANT NOTICE
We recommend that any prospective buyer views lots prior to purchase or has a representive do this on his/her behalf. Any condition report given by the auctioneer prior to auction is based on an opinion and should not be taken as a definitive statement of fact.
Any subsequent issues or disputes arising, based on condition reports given prior to auction, will not be entertained.
Fonsie Mealy Auctioneers reserve the right to withdraw or adjust any lot prior to the auction without notice. Any such lots so affected will be announced on the auction day. The auctioneer reserves the right to decline bidding from any prospective bidder.
N.B. All lots purchased are held, pending collection, at the buyer's risk from the fall of the auction hammer.
While the auctioneer endeavours to answer clients enquiries, we accept no responsibility or liability for any inaccuracy in auction results given verbally during the sale days.
We recommend that clients should only make such enquiries following the conclusion of the Sale.
N.B.: Please note the auctioneers offer no After Sale Guarantee whatsoever, with regard to mechanical and electrical items, vintage motor vehicles or firearms. We accept no subsequent liability for any damage, loss or injury arising from the use of the foregoing.
IMPORTANT INFORMATION REGARDING CONDITION REPORTS
All property is sold “as is”, with all faults, without any representation or warranty of any kind by Fonsie Mealy Auctioneers or the seller. Buyers are responsible for satisfying themselves concerning the condition of the property and the matters referred to in the catalogue entry.
All statements by Fonsie Mealy Auctioneers made orally or in writing elsewhere, are statements of opinion and are not to be relied on as statements of fact. Such statements do not constitute a representation, warranty or assumption of liability by Fonsie Mealy Auctioneers of any kind. References in the catalogue entry or the condition report to damage or restoration are for guidance only and should be evaluated by personal inspection by the bidder or a knowledgeable representative. The absence of such a reference does not imply that an item is free from defects or restoration, nor does a reference to particular defects imply the absence of any others. Estimates of the selling price should not be relied on as a statement that this is the price at which the item will sell or its value for any other purpose. All measurements are approximate.
In the case of Wines and Spirits, Fonsie Mealy Auctioneers do all that is possible to indicate the accuracy of levels. Such levels may change between cataloguing and sales. A risk of cork failure must be taken into account by any potential buyer. The Auctioneers will not entertain any price negotiation or return of purchases nor will substitutes be provided in the case of breakage or error of description. Labels may invariably be stained or torn. Fonsie Mealy Auctioneers reserve the right to open original cases prior to sale to describe levels and condition.
FIREARMS
Special Note Regarding Firearms
A specific Permit or Licence must be produced relating to the Firearm purchased, before same can be removed from our Premises. Please contact your local Gardai.
The shipping of antique firearms and weapons to destinations, particularly outside of the E.U., requires compliance with the stringent regulations governing such. We recommend that intending purchasers seek guidance from our designated shipping company as to these issues , Mail Boxes Etc ,Dublin, Tel. 01.6710400 info@mbedublin 2.com or Pack and Send Belfast Tel ; +44 (0) 2890 219003 Email belfasteast@packsend.co.uk
All decommissioned and non-firing firearms are sold as such and the auctioneer bears no responsibility for any subsequent re-commissioning and use by the purchaser and for any regulation or licensing that may then apply.
Lots subject to C.I.T.E.S. cannot be sold to buyers based in countries outside the Europoean Union ( E.U. ) Permission to export such items outside of the E.U. is very restricted / most probably unobtainable.
From time to time digital equipment is used to dispaly items for sale at auction.This service is merely a reminder to the customer of items previously viewed during view days.
We do not guarantee the quality of the item viewed, the accuracy of the the digital image or guarantee the item on display is the item being sold. Disputes arising as a result of digital image display will not be entertained.
Live bidding is subject to occasional interruption and loss of connection and audio / digital image streaming. These are technical issues beyond the auctioneers control, We accept no responsibility for any bids missed, placed in error, or omitted as a result of the foregoing.
Collection from Howth Castle - No Collections on sale days.
Collections - From 12 Noon - 4.00 pm Friday 24th September and resuming on Monday 27th Septmber at 12 Noon until 4 pm -and subsequent weekdays. No collections available at weekends.
We request that all items purchased must be collected from the sale vanue ( Howth Castle ) by 15.00 on Friday. 24th September.
Overseas purchasers are requested to arrange collection and shipment as soon as possible, and by no later than Friday, 1st October.
We recommend the following Shipping Companies to assist you with collection and shipment.
Please contact them directly to obtain shipping cost quote, delivery schedule, etc.
For; Books & Manuscripts :
Mail Boxes Etc ,Dublin. Tel. 01.6710400 Email info@mbedublin2.com
Pack and Send Belfast . Tel ; +44 (0) 2890 219003 Email belfasteast@packsend.co.uk
For Larger Items.
Gibbons Removals Kilkenny 056.7760444 Email info@gibbonsremovals.com
Tel: +353 (0)57 87 36596
Web: www.MovingHome.ie E-mail: info@movinghome.ie
Carlyle Fine Art Services ; Dublin. Tel; 087.2890898 Email david@davidcarlyle.ie
Oman Removals and Storage ,Kill Co. Kildare. Tel 045.886300 Email info@oman.ie
